JL may have good taste in Mexican food, but to the extent he is a New Yorker he is operating under a handicap.
Mexican food in NYC is a disaster...mostly because the city has so few Mexicans among its spanish speaking people. Most places serve black beans rather than the refried pinto kind. harumph.
A significant number are spanish/chinese places...or the latest meme, the "fresh tortillas" places that are almost always chinese or korean owned. I mean I eat at these places...in a fast food kind of way...but I don't think of it as being Mexican food. It is...something else...
Chicago, because it has a real Mexican community, has great Mexican food.
Back in Chicago any place that didn't serve menudo was looked upon with suspicion. (Not that I like menudo...I actually don't...but no menudo was always a dead giveaway of a place that didn't count on local Mexicans eating there...ergo...).
In NYC I've yet to find one of my faves...carnitas con mole...a dish that could give an olympic marathon runner overnight cholesterol disease it is so rich. Big chunks of fried pork in mole. Yum!
Also Albondigas...spicy Mexican meatballs that often have a big chunk of hardboiled egg in the middle. I also liked getting soups at Mexican places in Chicago. Chicken soup, for example, would come in a giant bowl with a whole chicken leg on the bone in there along with breast meat...giant chunks of potato and carrot...and then a small plate with fresh chopped onion and greens you would dump in at the table right before eating it so it had all this crunchy stuff in it.
Damn...I'm hungy now...