I don't think it was such a bad call. In real time, the ball looked foul. With the benefit of slow motion replay, it looked like the ball was slicing into foul territory and as it did so, barely grazed the line. It is the kind of call that gets missed many times every year because it's a close play and there is no instant replay in baseball on such calls. You never hear about it on those other occasions. To me it is not that big a deal. If you microanalyze other no hitters there are blown calls, lucky plays, etc. and if you try hard enough you can asterisk all of them. If you try hard enough you can asterisk a whole bunch of World Series as well, starting with last year when the Rangers lost because Nelson Cruz was afraid to run into the right field wall and let a ball that was an out drop in. If a defensive replacement had been inserted in right for Cruz, the Rangers would be 2011 WS Champs.