I know there WERE two of them. Before my hobby time, but when I was kid family had a shop in the Allen Blvd industrial park and there was one over there down block from the original Sugar Bush.
There is an old UG thread from the era you speak
@billyS -
https://utopiaguide.pl/forums/index.php?threads/girls-at-sinderellas.13648/
If google is accurate this place has 24/7 hours and never closes which is crazy for LI and may be attractive to certain people.
Wow, I looked at that thread and had completely forgotten about the other Sinderella on Allen Blvd. That's not the place I got crabs, I was talking about the place on Commack Road
I do remember that encounter at Sugar Bush.
The Sinderella on Allen never had any type of girls and from what I remember they advertised in the back of Newsday by the sports section. Old Timers here will remember places like Cuccies and the Gaslight Parlor also had ads in Newsday.
I remember going into the place on Allen and they did have private booths where you could watch porn by feeding a machine quarters but then I think they switched to a homo room where the booths only had curtains?
I'm a little fuzzy on this. Maybe it was two different places, and then Sugar Bush eventually becoming the third on Allen?
I do remember the first place on Allen advertising as "New York City Adult Style Entertainment". Maybe that one wasn't Sinderellas because then maybe that places closed and Sinderellas opened up with the homo room?
Anyway the original place was in the early nineties for sure. Way before UG.