First off, I was responding specifically to your statement that "this team will not be better next year."
During spring training we will get to see "how good Davis is" and will know what we can "expect from Johan." We will also know whether Wright and Reyes are staying.
Regardless of what happens, the 2012 team will be better than the 2011 team. Why?
Because by the end of spring training the "question marks" will be gone.
In the simplistic sense, we will know who is staying and who is playing. There are so many variations of the team that could finally take the field on opening day that it would fill a book. To begin with, it depends on whether Wright and Reyes stay and whether Davis can still perform. Then you have to wonder whether Bay and Pagan will be here, too. What about pitching and a catcher, as you pointed out?
But worst case scenario, even if they're all gone and we are just left with a squad of AAA call-ups, we'll still be a better team. Because at least then we'll know what we have. No more questions. That's my point.
C'mon, man. At least let them get through spring training before you write them off. And for the record, I am not saying that the 2012 will compete in the NL East. I still see them as a third-place team. But one with a winning record and a solid core of players. And because of that, I think we can win the wild card in 2013 and will go on to win the series.
P.S. I do agree with you that Collins is fine and that the team has not given up. Didn't the Atlanta series show that, Steve?