#1
To begin at the beginning - this is sometime around 2005 or 6. I trade emails with a girl from CL - we tried a handful of times to set something up, but it never materializes. I didn't realize until much later that the girl in question - let's call her K - it wasn't the first time we had talked.
Months later - and her with a different email address (which is why I didn't figure it out earlier) - I place a CL ad. One of the raunchy ones you used to be able to get away with - like "I want you to meet me, get on your knees, lick and suck my balls until I unload all over your face...then do it again" sort of things. So a girl answers - we cut a deal, and then we meet at a midtown hotel - grab a couple of drinks to get acquainted. Then I send her up to my room with one of the keys and tell her to wait for me. She performed admirably - we had a really good time - and within 45 minutes coaxed 2 gigantic loads out of me, and off she went.
I was excited - as you all know, CL back in the days was hit or miss, but when you found a good girl, you tried to keep her (or at least I did). It isn't that I don't like variety, it is that the good ones are so hard to find (a mix of looks/chemistry/performance/reliability/etc) that if you let someone get away from you - don't keep them in rotation, someone else will snap them up. Very much like SA today, except that because SA is a site it isn't quite as random as fishing on CL.
My intent, with this one, was to keep seeing her.