You're giving up too much in the Oakland trade although we agree on the targets.
Semien and Marte peaked last year, who ever gets them will over pay.
I'm not that high on Castellanos. I'd rather have Conforto.
I don't mind Conforto at all, Nice lefty bat would play well in stadium. He better than Gallo.
We giving up spare parts on my proposed trade for Olsen. All Yankee fans, myself included need to get over the Torres hype. He hit those 38 hrs in a year with a juiced ball and hit 33% of them against the Orioles. He's a 12-14 hr type max. Either one of those MnM boys would slot in well after Monty and are better than Taillon.
Regarding Semien and Marte, even if they peaked and you can get them each at 3 years for a higher annual average salary, they better than Hicks and Wade/Urshela (at SS)
Even if Marte falls off to 280 batting average and steals 35 bases with A+ defense its worth it. He will likely score 100+ runs, he's not getting Paid to hit hrs, he's getting paid to set the table.
Semien, I agree with you, but if he came cheaper and with less years and still hit 25-30 hrs with a 270 average, with great defense, I am all in until Volpe/Peraza are ready. Can't see them paying 250-300 million for a SS when they have 2 highly regarded SS prospects. Semien or Segar could move to 3B if either were signed. I can't see Correa agreeing to move to 3B.
Which brings me to those guys, one will get moved this off season you would think. Possibly for an arm?
Lot to consider, but as a Yankee fan I am cautiously excited for the rebirth and getting some swag back in the Bronx!