The Girls That got Away.....

#23
I was definitely spoiled on my first encounter. It was in 2006 with an agency called L.I. Confidential.I made an appt with 'Candy' who was highly recommended by phone guy 'Vincent'.
It occurred in a well known spot on route 109. The woman who arrived was the proverbial girl next door who looked more like the girl in one of your college courses that you'd never have the nerve to speak to. I met with her several times and she subsequently went independent calling herself Angelica Sterling and then Jessica Knightly. I lost track of her but recently tried to contact Jessica but was told it wasn't the same woman. What a shame but what a Memory!
 
#24
An independent Asian lady I met in an apartment setup in Flushing. She stood 5'-9", long legs, long wavy hair to her mid back, and had the girl next door look. In bed her lust knew no bounds.

Our sessions were like a porn shoot. Sometimes the MMS would look after we were spent in bed and look at us in awe. Kept seeing her off and on for over a year- even when she went solo.

She made my body do things I thought was not possible at my advanced years. Last time I saw her was epic, and I still get aroused thinking about the encounter. Spoiled me through and through. She used to sneak me in at her last spot, which was her home in a shared apartment. I got busted sneaking out one night by civvie housemate. We agreed to hotel hookups but when the appointed time came she stopped responding.

Still on the prowl for her, if nothing else to know how she is faring. Suspect she got caught up with wrong crowd. She started getting tattoos- and I knew it wasn't her thing. Later learned it was a Chinese gang thing for girls affiliated with them.

Best I ever had.

Regards,

Pops
 
#25
Ah, Asian women and the place that they hold in our hearts and groins!

Another one that got away was Korean girl called Jeannie who worked at the Lucky Spa in north Patchogue back around 15 years ago. This girl was absolute perfection, someone you would expect to find at a high end spot in Manhattan that catered to Japanese businessmen, not a LI AMP. Her face was drop-dead gorgeous, her body was that of a model's and her tits couldn’t be real only because perfection like that is simply never found in nature. She was friendly, sweet and frisky. Once, while we were laying on our sides and I was taking her from behind, she was looking in the mirror on the far wall and said so sweet and innocently in her faltering English, “Look at us making love.”

I saw her on about four occasions and the next time I went, there was a handwritten sign on the locked door saying they had moved to a new location. Unfortunately, the address written on the note was that of the SCPD fifth precinct. Cop joke, I guess. The place was busted and I never saw her again, but I would have followed that one anywhere.
 
#27
If I had to pick one that got away, it would have to be the Sophia Belle/Kelly Keegan doubles match. Only because this will never ever happen again and they were so revered at the time.
 
#30
If I had to pick one that got away, it would have to be the Sophia Belle/Kelly Keegan doubles match. Only because this will never ever happen again and they were so revered at the time.
I was lucky enough to have that doubles match twice. So i give you two or my favorite memories of those encounters.
Standing between the two beds with both girls on there knees coordinating their efforts to tongue me tip of shaft to balls in alternating directions in synchronization.
2nd would be on my knees on the bed with Kelly grinding/twerking her awesome ass on my sick while Sophia was on her knees rimming me and sucking my balls.
Both standouts for me and have been used in metal recalls when with the SO
 
#31
I was lucky enough to have that doubles match twice. So i give you two or my favorite memories of those encounters.
Standing between the two beds with both girls on there knees coordinating their efforts to tongue me tip of shaft to balls in alternating directions in synchronization.
2nd would be on my knees on the bed with Kelly grinding/twerking her awesome ass on my sick while Sophia was on her knees rimming me and sucking my balls.
Both standouts for me and have been used in metal recalls when with the SO
\m/ > __< \m/

Metal Recall
 
#34
Met this curly haired 20 years old mixed mami named veronica in queens not too far from st. Johns ... she gave me the best bbj in my car i wanted to do more but lost her contact. This was like 4 years ago or so. I still think about her. She would post in queens cl, with the tittle lollipop specials
 
#35
My “got away” list includes Mistress Jackie, Brooke from DC, and both of the Ashleys (201 & Stonehedge). Jackie and I had a way of ringing each other’s bells. I truly miss her on many levels.
 
#36
Marcela the super thick Latina Milf/Gilf bronze colored tan lines Brazilian use to post on Eros almost like 8 years ago or so super thick I still wonder if her booty was real. Used to jiggle like jello from the back super thick lady not fat but phat. She had JLO type measurements 34D-27-40 like 5’2 or 5’3 close to an early version of Kim Kardashian. At that time back then I was new to the hobby did not realize how unique that booty and body would be in this hobby kept exploring others and lost contact with her then she stopped posting altogether, I think she worked in New Jersey or lived out there part time and also in Brazil coming here on work visas etc. I should have just seen her instead of looking elsewhere smh until she retired hindsight is always 20/20. I haven’t met too many ladies with a booty like hers all natural and all with such a huge phatass on such a small frame don’t think I haven’t tried maybe only two or three in almost ten years not a great batting average lol. That is one lady I wish would come back or find a Milf just like her with the same amazing body and BOOTY!
 
#37
Really enjoying this thread! I don’t have any providers that I pine for really. The ones I think a lot about are the CL girls that would answer some of the crazy ads I’d post over the years. My favorite ( and I swear I was the first to post this back in the very early days of CL) was for someone to take my profile pictures for an adult website. I had to have met 40-50 girls this way. I’d offer $50-$100 to meet them and they would use my camera (so I knew I’d control the pictures). 90% of the time it would lead to a hook up and 75% of those ended with sex. My favorite was this petite AA that I ended up meeting several times. In our first visit, as she was taking pics, she just started undressing. Told me she wanted me to have some real inspiration. Had me lay down on the bed and then dropped the camera, lifted up my leg, and began running me. Not light outside rim, full on, wet, tongue diving rim. It was the craziest. And she stayed here for a long time, stroking, bbbj and rimming. Flipped it around and I went down on her and she almost made me deaf when she clapped her legs so tight as she came. We then started having sex and she likes it hard and fast. And then in her ass. Wow she was a champ. I’ll never forget that day.
She was in a bad marriage and desperately wanted out. Eventually she moved to Orlando and we tried to get together but it never happened. After a couple years her number and email stopped working and that was it. She was a dream come true, wish I could have her back for one more round!
 
#38
There was a cute AA girl that worked out of the gaslight motel on 112 about 5 or 6 years ago. She told me that her name was Emily. She was about 21 from south Queens. Her ad on bp said magically delicious.
She was small framed with b cups and a great bubble ass with a girl next door face. She was a bright girl and seemed like she had other plans in life.
she wore nothing but these knee high striped toe sox that made her legs go on forever. I used to pin them behind her head.
I would kiss her thighs but she would stop me from getting a lick. I told her that she couldn't blame me for trying.
I always did.
I saw her probably 4 or 5 Times. That's alot for me. Then poof. Gone.. No more posts anywhere. No trace,
She's probably a nurse someplace.

I still think about her. :(
 
#40
Great thread... i think most of us remember at least one above all the rest. My got away girl is going back atleast 15 years ago.. her name was Montana...yes.. her real name..i saw her drivers liscence. She was from Pittsburgh.an ex penn state cheerleader.. ..absolutly stunning for those of us that love fair skinned auburn hair girls...perfect body with a set of perky B's that aimed up at the moon... and an ass that time cant erase from memory.. i used to see her in smithtown almost weekly..we then over time became friendly and she would meet me in A.C....and we would do an over night.. dinner.. ect.. and she would dress up just the way i love.. black short cocktail dress...heels stockings garter belt...just amazing... i remember comming out of the bathroom and seeing her up against the window glass in our room...ass arched out showing me that beautiful gap n cookie...boardwalk lit up in fromt of her making the hottest silhouette....oh my.... what memories never fade...
 
Top