Best Steakhouse in Nassau or Suffolk counties

[trader1]

Suggestions on where one could get a great steak on LI-
Have been to Rothmans, B&C, & Insignia—
A nearby cigar bar ( or in house) would be a plus plus

 

[Uniquelyme]

Suggestions on where one could get a great steak on LI-
Have been to Rothmans, B&C, & Insignia—
A nearby cigar bar ( or in house) would be a plus plus

Peter Luger, there was a cigar shop few stores down from there. You're missing an N . Rothmann's

 

[Satisfied customer]

The Palm Court in Eisenhower has great food and a cigar bar upstairs

 

[joeyboy]

Cliff's Rendezvous in Riverhead used to be good.... haven't been there in a long time though.

 

[L.I.Paul]

Fogo de Chao, a Brazilian steakhouse in the Walt Whitman Mall, opened last month with some very good reviews.
It's on my to-do list.

 

[OSMonger]

Bryant and Coopers is hands down the best steak on LI IMO. I’ve been to at least 12 different steakhouses and I’d always go back to B&C.

 

[Raptor808]

High End LI
George Martins Strip is awesome.
Tellers would be number two

High End NYC
Wilensky Grill
Old Homestead

Normal Range
Majors
Harley’s

Hope this helps.

 

[Raptor808]

Fogo de Chao, a Brazilian steakhouse in the Walt Whitman Mall, opened last month with some very good reviews.
It's on my to-do list.

They have one in Carl Place. Pretty good but not the same since Covid.

 

[Raptor808]

Bryant and Coopers is hands down the best steak on LI IMO. I’ve been to at least 12 different steakhouses and I’d always go back to B&C.

There Cajun steak is really good.

 

[AlwaysHavingFun]

Go to Blackstone on 110 and head over to gossip downstairs for cigars after.

 

[LISteve]

Tellers is great, I like Blackstones too, plus Paces.

 

[Mick34]

High End LI
George Martins Strip is awesome.
Tellers would be number two

High End NYC
Wilensky Grill
Old Homestead

Normal Range
Majors
Harley’s

Hope this helps.

Been most of mentioned. Majors is much less costly and after 30yrs I am still loving it. Tellers ,Blackstones as god as well

 

[billyS]

I feel like we've had this thread before

 

[Monger007]

Vintage Steakhouse in St James.

 

[boneengineer]

Cliff's Rendezvous in Riverhead used to be good.... haven't been there in a long time though.

I have a version of their steak marinade recipe if you can't get there anymore

 

[joeyboy]

I have a version of their steak marinade recipe if you can't get there anymore

I can get there ...just haven't been there. Now I'm hungry! Lol

 

[boneengineer]

If you are close to North shore of Suffolk. Robkees in Northport is reasonable and tasty... Best lunch deals in the area. Just have cash!!!!

 

[lightweight]

If anyone’s been to the elbow Room in the north fork, I have their marinade recipe. And it’s amazing, among my favorite marinades of all time.

INGREDIENTS:
- 2 medium onions- 1 cup soy sauce
- 3 cloves garlic- ½ cup gravy master
- 1 tsp Lawry’s seasoned salt

INSTRUCTIONS:
- Mix all ingredients except the seasoned salt in a blender until it becomes paste-like
- Add seasoned salt and stir
- Cover the meat with mixture
- Marinate 5 hours, turning every hour (I just put in ziplock bag)

• Do not use aluminum pan to marinate

One of my favorite places.

 

[Conquistador]

IMC in Huntington Village is a go to of mine.
Sur, also in Huntington Village is a great Argentinian steak house. Very small and get full quick.
Tellers is also a great one to try.
Opus, previously know as One North is great also.
Hope this helps

 

[trader1]

IMC in Huntington Village is a go to of mine.
Sur, also in Huntington Village is a great Argentinian steak house. Very small and get full quick.
Tellers is also a great one to try.
Opus, previously know as One North is great also.
Hope this helps

Been to Sur a couple times
Post lockdowns, quality a deteriorated slightly