I don't trust either of them. Not going to use either in any of my wagers.
I just watched the SA Derby and Taiba's maiden win. Boy, he looked like he had plenty in reserve when he went by Messier.
Here's what impressed me about his SA Derby:
He broke alertly and if Smith wanted the lead it was his for the taking but took hold and tracked off the two colts ahead of him.
On the final turn, you could see that Smith was sitting on GO and when engaged in a duel with Messier, beat him quite easily. Messier really wasn't tiring, Taiba was accelerating by him. If you have a chance go back and watch the SA Derby again and let me know if your opinion changes.
The downside is that outside of Messier, who I still respect, the rest of the field was terrible. The beyer was 102 the highest of any prep race.
He sold for 1.7 million at a two year old in training sale, as a yearly he fetched about $150,000. (Nice score for the breeder)
My instincts suggest that Taiba may be something special.