The used to be a hole in the wall place called
FOUR &
TWENTY BLACKBIRDS PIE SHOP in Orient Village Business District (Business district consisted of a grand total of the pie shop, a tiny general store that doubled as the post office — you had to go down Village Lane off of Main Rd (Rt 25)just before you got to the Ferry). Girl with lots of tats and piercings ran the place. I think it had 2 tables inside and a picnic table outside. I would always stop in to/from ferry for pie and coffee. If you didn't know it was there you would never know about it. Alas, closed this year
Anyway they got the pies from
FOUR &
TWENTY BLACKBIRDS PIE SHOP 439 3rd Avenue, Brooklyn, NY 11216. So evidently they trucked the pies 110 mile from Brooklyn to this place — very, very strange business model. If you are in the Brooklyn area (I'm never) stop in
Best pies I ever had. Coffee was always made fresh by the cup.